Author Topic: Winter garage. Heat it, Dehumidify, air condition or leave it alone??  (Read 14436 times)

Drewtee

  • Full Member
  • Silver
  • ****
  • England, Kent, Sevenoaks
  • Posts: 392
Hi,

A question for those of us that don't have all year sun (you lucky lot)

As the weather is starting to turn i was wondering if it's worth investing in either heating my garage,  De humidifying it or a portable air conditioning unit.
The garage has an inch space at the top of a double door for ventilation.

Is it overkill or does it really benefit our cars in cold damp winter months???

There will obviously be extra expense to do this, if i go ahead, which method is the most cost effective?

Any advice greatly appreciated.

Andy

Andy Tee

Rhd 5 speed 728h with parchment interior
White Californian 280sl LHD
W111 3.5 Cab and Coupe both RHD

knockmacool

  • Guest
Andy

Have a look at this thread

http://www.sl113.org/forums/index.php?topic=10418.0

To tell you the truth, most of my barn doors are slatted rather than solid, and seem to do pretty well with ventilation, so I still haven't committed to anything yet.

Drew

JamesL

  • Full Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • United Kingdom, London, London
  • Posts: 3527
I remember the prior thread on this. I also remember seeing cars stored in a too dry place and the leather is shot (albeit stored for a long time)

Mine will sit in the garage which happens to contain the heat pump and hot water tank for the house. That will keep the edge off. I have no dehumidifier etc, but do have a draughty garage door
James L
Oct69 RHD 280 in DB906 with cognac leather

Drewtee

  • Full Member
  • Silver
  • ****
  • England, Kent, Sevenoaks
  • Posts: 392

Have a look at this thread

http://www.sl113.org/forums/index.php?topic=10418.0


Thanks Knockmacool (Drew!

That's a good thread with lots of info. it didn't come up in my original search.

I remember the prior thread on this. I also remember seeing cars stored in a too dry place and the leather is shot (albeit stored for a long time)


leather is a good point which i hadn't thought off, maybe a leather car product could help.

At the end of the day it's easy to get to obsessed over these things and i just want to make sure the very cold garage does not cause a problem but again its probably overkill.
Andy Tee

Rhd 5 speed 728h with parchment interior
White Californian 280sl LHD
W111 3.5 Cab and Coupe both RHD

RickM

  • Guest
The scourge I face every winter is....Mice.

I have to stay on top of them with traps, and those hanging moth ball discs.

Unless you have very high humidity I'd leave be for just the winter..... here's a good desiccant product: http://www.americanfiltration.com/dehumidifier%20packets%20stadri.html

With high humidity another concern is condensation settling on the chrome.

thelews

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, WI, Mequon
  • Posts: 1938
I have a well insulated and well sealed garage.  The heat, forced air gas, is set at 45 degrees and the humidity pretty much stays at 45% all winter.  The main doors are not opened all winter while the cars are not driven, just the service doors to get in.  I'll push up the heat to 55 or 60 when I go in to fool around from time to time.
Enjoy some pictures at this link:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/8292359@N06/sets/72157603240571101/show/

John - Wisconsin
1967 Early 250 SL Red/Caviar, Manual #1543
1961 190 SL 23K miles
1964 Porsche 356
1970 Porsche 911E
1991 BMW 318is
1966 Jaguar XKE
1971 Alfa Romeo GTV 1750

JOS

  • Guest
If I was a car. I would like the same pleasures of life afforded to my master.

Heat if it is cold
A/C if it is hot.
A Dehumidifier if the humidity is over 65%
Leather conditioner to keep me soft
New fluids to keep me ready
Tires of the ground
A nice car cover to keep the dust and uv rays of my $6,000 paint job.
A kiss good night. :) :)
JOS

Drewtee

  • Full Member
  • Silver
  • ****
  • England, Kent, Sevenoaks
  • Posts: 392
The scourge I face every winter is....Mice.


I've just invested in a couple of these devices after reading a thread on this forum.
http://www.ratzapper.com/

No mice caught yet which hopefully means we have no mice  :-\

If I was a car. I would like the same pleasures of life afforded to my master.

Heat if it is cold
A/C if it is hot.
A Dehumidifier if the humidity is over 65%
Leather conditioner to keep me soft
New fluids to keep me ready
Tires of the ground
A nice car cover to keep the dust and uv rays of my $6,000 paint job.
A kiss good night. :) :)
JOS

........and a brandy to keep the cold nights out :)


Andy Tee

Rhd 5 speed 728h with parchment interior
White Californian 280sl LHD
W111 3.5 Cab and Coupe both RHD

Ulf

  • Associate Member
  • Gold
  • *****
  • Denmark, Fredericksberg, Rungsted Kyst
  • Posts: 838
I don't know whether these - or similar items - are available outside Europe, but it sure is a great idea.
It's a solar driven ventilation system - the air is dried and heated to 15 degrees centigrade above the outside temperature in an insulated glass compartment and a solar cell drives the fan blowing the heated, dry air into your basement, garage or house keeping the dampness out...
I'm getting one for my summer house and one for my garage - they're not cheap, but running cost is nil and so is CO2-emission...

Here's the link: www.solarventi.com

Best regards

Ulf
1965 230 SL in silver (DB180)
1982 Land Rover Series III SWB
2008 Jaguar XF 3.0
2005 Mini Cooper

graphic66

  • Guest
I put a plastic tub filled with good old lump charcoal in my car every Winter. It is a great dessicant and in the Spring I cook with it.

johnshenry

  • Guest
Re: Winter garage. Heat it, Dehumidify, air condition or leave it alone??
« Reply #10 on: October 22, 2009, 18:32:20 »
I've just invested in a couple of these devices after reading a thread on this forum.
http://www.ratzapper.com/

No mice caught yet which hopefully means we have no mice  :-\

........and a brandy to keep the cold nights out :)




I'll second that ratzapper.  Mine is 4-0 now in every case I even suspected a mouse.  I have used it to catch them in the in between floor spaces in the house too.

Drewtee

  • Full Member
  • Silver
  • ****
  • England, Kent, Sevenoaks
  • Posts: 392
Re: Winter garage. Heat it, Dehumidify, air condition or leave it alone??
« Reply #11 on: October 29, 2009, 20:11:47 »
I thought I'd add this text to the thread from a website called ‘Dry it out’ as after looking around the internet it seems to be very good information for anyone interested. (I’m not affiliated to the website or in a position to recommend their products...blah blah)
   
   
   All air contains a certain amount of moisture. The ratio of the amount of moisture in the air compared to the maximum that the air can hold at a given temperature is called the Relative Humidity or RH and is expressed as a percentage. For a given amount of moisture, the higher the air temperature the lower the RH%. Equally the lower the air temperature the higher the RH%.
   It is the cooling of air that causes the problems. As air cools it can hold less and less moisture until a point is reached where the air is fully saturated (100% RH) - known as the dew point. If the car, tools, or anything else in this environment, is at a temperature below the dew point of this air then moisture is given up by the air as condensation. This manifests itself as wet car surfaces, rust on tools, damp paperwork etc. Because the moisture condensed out from the air is pure distilled water it is also the ideal environment to encourage the growth of moulds and fungal spores.
   The solution to the problem is to reduce the dew point to a level below the temperature of any part of the garage and its contents AND to keep the RH% within controlled levels.
 
   THE TARGET ENVIRONMENT
The aim is to arrive at a stable environment between 40% and 60% RH independent of outside temperature. Below 60% bare metal can be left out in the open and rust/corrosion all but stops. Below 40% RH leather and wood can dry too much and will become brittle and crack. This target environment can be achieved in several ways:
 
   HEATING
By heating the garage the air becomes warm enough to hold the moisture and condensation stops - well nearly stops - if you bring a cold car in from outside into a nice warm garage then condensation occurs immediately (like taking a milk bottle out of the fridge). Heating also has one other serious drawback - cost. To heat the average garage sufficiently will require several kW of power either as electric heaters or radiators. This heat will need to be continuously applied through cold weather to stop condensation and this will be very expensive to run.
 
   VENTILATION SYSTEMS
This can take the form of natural ventilation built into the garage or forced ventilation by installation of a suitable extraction or positive pressure device. Ventilation will remove the stale high humidity air from the building at little or no cost. One current commercial system on the market incorporates a small heater to aim to lower the RH% of the incoming air. The reality of these systems is that the air that enters the building from outside to replace the exhausted air will still be high in humidity. Claims that for every 1 degree increase in temperature the RH% will reduce by 5% are frankly inaccurate, as the relationship between temperature and RH% is not constant. Furthermore, any temperature rise has to be sustainable throughout the whole of the garage volume - think how little a 3kW fan heater does to the garage temperature. There is no control over absolute humidity level in the garage - only of the air entering the garage. The average humidity level in the building can still remain above the point where deterioration can occur.
 
   PLASTIC ENCLOSURES
Several manufacturers supply systems that enclose the car completely in a plastic ‘bubble’ and provide low volume ventilation airflow that evens out the humidity within the bag and maintains its shape. These systems stop condensation quite successfully and are relatively cheap to run. The downside is that the systems make no attempt to control the RH%. The contents of the bubble can still be at a RH% well above safe levels. Another disadvantage is a practical one - these systems are fine if you want to move the car very infrequently. If you use, or work on, the car in the winter then getting it in and out of the bubble can be laborious and adds to the wear and tear of the bag itself. It is also obvious that only the air within the bubble is controlled - everything else within the garage area is unprotected - tools, stored parts etc.
 
   DEHUMIDIFICATION
By removing the moisture from the air in the garage with a car storage dehumidifier everything stored in the garage will remain condensation and corrosion free. Dehumidifiers are cheap to run, quiet in use and largely maintenance free. Suitably sized units will reduce and then maintain the humidity within the 40-60% RH target environment. In-built humidistats ensure that the air does not become too dry or too wet by turning the machines on and off as required. A correctly chosen dehumidifier will tolerate periodic changes of air such as opening the garage door or internal door. Furthermore, the action of dehumidification will bring the building as well as the contents into moisture equilibrium after a few weeks. If you then bring a wet car into the garage after a run in the rain it will actually dry it out for you!
   There are two main types of dehumidification equipment on the market - each use a different method to extract moisture from the air.
 
   CONDENSATE DEHUMIDIFIERS
By far and away the most popular type of dehumidifier, certainly for domestic applications is the condensate type. A condensate dehumidifier uses the principle of dew-point to its advantage. Air is passed over a cold coil and is cooled to below dew point thus giving up its moisture as condensation on the coil. This condensation drips from the coil into a collecting tank below or is piped away to a drain. The dry air is then passed over a hot coil before exiting the unit. The air coming out of the dehumidifier is a degree or two warmer than that going in. Dehumidifiers using this principle are small in dimensions and easy to install - just requiring a mains power point. If you want the water to drain away continuously then a pipe can be attached through a removable blanking plug on the machine. The machines require no regular maintenance other than periodic cleaning of the built-in air filter and can be expected to last for 10-15 years. All modern machines use CFC free refrigerants.
   A word of warning - Do not use standard domestic dehumidifiers in an unheated garage environment. They will not work when the ambient temperature drops below about 10C. The condensing coil becomes so cold that it freezes solid and the dehumidifier stops working. All the machines Dry-it-Out supply have 'Hot Gas Defrost'. Machines with Hot Gas Defrost detect the onset of freezing on the coil and either reverse the flow of refrigerant or vent warm air internally to automatically defrost the condensing coil. A dehumidifier with Hot Gas Defrost will operate at ambient temperatures right down to freezing point and most will stand -5C without machine damage.
 
   ADSORPTION DEHUMIDIFIERS
To control the larger volumes of, for instance, a commercial car store, a different type of dehumidifier has traditionally been used - an adsorption dehumidifier. Adsorption dehumidifiers use a completely different principle to extract the moisture from the air.
   Air is passed through a high surface area rotor (rather like a catalytic converter to look at) that is impregnated with silica-gel. As the air passes through the rotor the moisture is adsorbed onto its surface. Part of the rotor is separated off from the main airflow. Through this part a small amount of air is ducted in from outside the building, heated and passed through the rotor. The moisture on the rotor is given up to the hot air which is then exhausted back outside the building as hot wet air. The newly-dried section of the rotor then re-emerges to the main airflow ready to adsorb more moisture. The rotor turns slowly making the operation continuous.
   The adsorption principle has important advantages. Firstly, its action is independent of temperature. An adsorption dehumidifier will operate as efficiently at -20C as +30C. Secondly the adsorption principle makes it possible to reduce the humidity levels to lower levels than condensate types. Larger adsorption dehumidifiers are permanently mounted units. However, Dry-it-Out Limited have a range of small portable completely self contained machine for domestic storage applications, such as the DD122FWmk3, the Ruby-Dry and the X-Dry.
   Dehumidifiers offer many advantages over alternative storage systems so it is little wonder that dehumidification is fast becoming the most popular solution to effective car storage in the UK.
 
Andy Tee

Rhd 5 speed 728h with parchment interior
White Californian 280sl LHD
W111 3.5 Cab and Coupe both RHD