Author Topic: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact  (Read 46861 times)

justininia

  • Guest
280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« on: July 23, 2012, 15:46:27 »
Good day to everyone.

We are in the middle of rebuilding a 1971 280SL with a 3.5L V8.  The chassis is painted and the engine is sitting waiting to get hoisted into the car.  Alas, we are already noticing some problem areas.  The passenger side exhaust manifold does not clear the steering arm or the firewall.  The power brake unit looks as though it needs to be moved 1.5" to the outside to fit correctly. 

We've heard of people making the switch which is why we are doing it.  I've been looking through the posts and seeing a lot of people reference the 3.5 engine swap but not finding anyone who has made the switch. (This is most likely due to my search criteria.) 

What I am hoping for is to find someone who has performed the engine installation and is willing to share the experience, good and bad, and be a point of contact for questions should they arise.  There looks to be several key areas that need addressing and a person with the actual experience would be extremely beneficial.  Is there someone with the experience who wouldn't mind being some electronic help?

Thanks for reading my post and happy motoring everyone.
Justin

JamesL

  • Full Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • United Kingdom, London, London
  • Posts: 3527
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #1 on: July 23, 2012, 17:04:25 »
In essence I am about as much use as a chocolate fireguard in this thread but the one contribution I can make is:

Which 3.5?
http://www.sl113.org/forums/index.php?topic=15199.0

http://www.sl113.org/forums/index.php?topic=6046.0

http://www.sl113.org/forums/index.php?topic=2023.0
James L
Oct69 RHD 280 in DB906 with cognac leather

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #2 on: July 26, 2012, 23:24:19 »
I didn't do a 3.5 swap in a Pagoda but I am in the process of fitting a 5.6. They are basically the same engines, the M117 having a bit higher block deck.

I know the 3.5 is period correct but if I were you I would seriously reconsider it: It is an iron block and is very heavy (I owned several W108/111 coupes fitted with one so I know it quite well). The Pagoda has this diving problem under hard braking and adding weight in the front is not going to help. Hatch & Sons claims the 3.5 is only 29lb heavier than the original M130 but I'm quite positive it's much heavier than that. The overall balance of the car will  also be affected and it will be nose heavy.

If I were you I would consider a later M116 (3.8 or 4.2) or M117 (5.0 or 5.6). They are basically the same engine but with an aluminum block. They are not heavier than the original M130 and they offer a bigger displacement. They can be dressed in D-jet trim to look period correct using the 3.5 or 4.5 D-jet hardware. I did it on a 5.0 M117 with very good results. otherwise the early K-jet system is very simple and reliable (This is the system I will be using on my 5.6 Pagoda).

To help answering some of your questions:

Some r107 (3.5 or 3.8?) came with  a right exhaust manifold which I believe will clear the steering arm/firewall. It has only one outlet when I guess yours have a double outlet. If you go the M117 route like me then the 560 SL manifold would also clear.

For the brake booster you have two options:

You can drill the firewall more on the left and shift the whole booster/pedal assy to the left. Or you can tillt the aluminum bracket by 45 degrees. this would require adaptor plates at both ends of the bracket to get the pedal assy and booster straight. I didn't decide which route to go for myself yet.

You may also use a smaller diameter booster, as found on some w114s for example.  I did that on my coupe conversion and it helped clearing the left cam cover.

Are you using an auto transmission or a manual transmission? If a manual one with the side shift system you will also have clearance problems in the trans tunnel. 

Keep us posted !
« Last Edit: July 26, 2012, 23:44:04 by GGR »

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #3 on: July 30, 2012, 16:36:53 »
Thanks for the replies.

In looking at that r107 exhaust, it looks like it will work.  Now we just have to find one.  

We have the period correct engine to place in the car, heavy steel and all.  We are using the front cross member out of a 280SE and heavier springs and shocks which should address the weight issues.  It looks like the transmission (automatic) should fit but we have only measured, not actually placed the unit in the car.  

The brake booster is already rebuilt so it looks like we are going to move it over about 3/4" and add a reinforcing plate to the firewall.  That is the easiest part of the modifications as we also have a modified pedal assembly already.

Thanks for the help.  I am sure more questions will pop up as we get closer to fitting a drive shaft and who knows what else.

Justin
« Last Edit: July 30, 2012, 17:58:35 by justininia »

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #4 on: July 30, 2012, 18:55:27 »
Apart from the very early fintails, front axle carrier is common to all these cars (108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113). You may consider using some W108/111 3.5 front springs, or even some W108 4.5 ones. It will help the diving issue. You can adjust height with the thickness of the top rubber shim, if needed. The 280SE 6 cylinder car springs may be a bit too weak. You may also consider transfering the battery behind the passenger seat (use a dry cell one in the passenger compartment) or in the trunck to help re-balance the weight distribution of the car.

You may use a W108/109/111 3.5 or a W108/109 4.5 pedal assembly as the brake pedal will have the correct offset and will seat where it should after you move the booster over: these cars also had their boosters more to the left to accomodate the V8 and thus the pedal is ending more to the right to compensate.

I would be curious to see how you modified the front right of the engine bay. I have fitted the alternator higher on my 5.6 and I think it will clear the sheet metal around the air filter housing, but I'm nor sure yet. Could you post a picture of that area? I see on the one you posted that you removed that part around the air filter. How are you going to hold the radiator?

Thanks.

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #5 on: August 04, 2012, 20:11:05 »
Good day!

We have a 116 and 117 set of exhaust manifolds with the only discernable difference being the drop for deck height.  The R107 manifolds look like the right fit for the job.  Would the manifolds from the aluminum 116 or 117 directly bolt up to the cast iron 116 engine?

Still working on modifying the mounting space for the brakes.  We heated the pedal arm and bent it rather than try the SE pedal assembly.  We are also playing the guessing game on how far over to move the booster unit.  My preference is just far enough to slip a socket onto the valve cover.  It makes the brake unit the last to install but that isn't the end of the world.

I'll get some pictures this afternoon.  Right now, all that has been modified in the engine compartment is removin that Sheila.  We are going to see if the radiator can be machined for a larger cooling capacity but hope to use the original radiator and mounts.

Cheers,
Justin

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #6 on: August 04, 2012, 20:44:53 »
Aluminum block M117s are fitted with heads with different port sizes and are also centered differently (compare exhaust gaskets to see what I mean). Heads fitted on iron block M116 and M117 and aluminum block M116 all have the ports sized and centered in the same way. In short, on an iron block M116 3.5 you can use other M116 (iron and aluminum block) exhaust manifolds and iron block M117 4.5 manifolds. You cannot use aluminum block M117 (5.0 and 5.6) manifolds. The latter will bolt on but the ports won't align properly and you will loose power.

For the booster, you should have at least two fingers clearance to allow for engine and front end mounts play. As mentioned earlier, you can fit a smaller diameter booster to help with the clearance.

Another point: W113 engine arms locate the engine a bit lower compared with sedan engine arms. I presume you are using 3.5/4.5 W108/109 engine arms. As a result your engine may sit a bit higher than it should. You should work on this and make sure the engine is properly located as it will also influence the location of the brake booster.

RCREEM

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #7 on: August 04, 2012, 22:31:03 »
Guten tag!

First off, thank you very much for all the help so far.  It has truly been welcomed.  Justin and I are working together on my car to get it up and going.  He's been kind enough to post the questions for me.

With the 116 arms on, there is only about an inch of clearance from the bottom of the engine to the front cross member.  With lower arms, I would think the deterioration of the motor mounts might cause it to ride on the steel.  We have a set of M130 (PN: 127 xx...) engine arms from a 113 chassis.  Those arms are longer and don't seem to fit plus they have the platform for the oil cooler. 

We decided on 2.125" to the driver's side should offer enough clearance for the brake booster from the engine and provide enough space for the remaining items that get routed through the firewall.  We also discovered that means moving the bracket under the steering column to support the pedal assembly.  Not a tremendous problem just the proverbial "one more thing".  Now off to get a 25/32 drill bit for the pedal arm.

Again, thank you for all the help you've provided thus far.

Dick


GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #8 on: August 04, 2012, 23:35:07 »
First off, thank you very much for all the help so far.  It has truly been welcomed.

You're welcome !

With the 116 arms on, there is only about an inch of clearance from the bottom of the engine to the front cross member.  With lower arms, I would think the deterioration of the motor mounts might cause it to ride on the steel.  We have a set of M130 (PN: 127 xx...) engine arms from a 113 chassis.  Those arms are longer and don't seem to fit plus they have the platform for the oil cooler. 

What chassis are your engine arms coming from? W108/109/111? or 107? or 116? They are not the same. Again, I presume you are using the 108/109/111 V8 ones.

What I was trying to say is that the Pagoda engine sits lower than in the sedans relative to the front axle carrier. I don't know by how much, I would need to compare W113 and sedan L6 engine arms. I believe the difference may be between 1 and 2 cm. You may want to reproduce this difference as much as possible so as not to have too much misalignement/angle with the driveshaft (otherwise you may end up with some vibrations). The W108/109/111 engine arms will put your crankshaft rotation axis at the same lavel as on sedans. If you feel you don't have enough clearance with the front axle carrier you could fit some shims in between the front axle mounts and the chassis rails to have the axle sit a tad lower (let's say by 1 cm; 6.3s have 2cm shims there). Don't lower it too much as you still want all the steering couplings to clear under the engine. If your car sits too high as a result you can fit thinner rubber shims on top of the front springs or shorten the springs ( but I think you will be OK because the 3.5 motor is way heavier than the L6 and you're using L6 springs so they will compress more).

Anyway, it should be a step by step process and you should then adjust accordingly at each step. I hopefully be there soon with my 5.6, though I will start the conversion from the rear first.

Keep us posted ! 
« Last Edit: August 04, 2012, 23:46:49 by GGR »

RCREEM

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #9 on: August 05, 2012, 04:56:36 »
Our "donor" car(s) were a '71 300 SEL which gave its core 3.5 M116 engine and a rebuilt auto trans.  We also dismantled a '72 280SE 4.5 junker and are using its complete front suspension assembly, incl springs, slotted rotors with the bigger brake pads, etc.  We have gone clear through it, so its pretty solid, and we hope it will have enough support with the 4.5 springs.  The motor support arms are from the W109 /3.5 engine.  The 113 is a '70 280SL chassis, but had no running gear when we rescued it (as a stripped hulk that had been "ebayed for parts"), so we don't have any way to compare the engine height in the chassis.  We have a couple of L6 engines, but both are out of sedans, incl the "127" part number support arms.  We really appreciate your in-depth explanation about the height in-chassis and will look into shimming the front sub-frame assembly down.  We don't have the (later model) auto trans in yet, but we are concerned about drive line angle.  Your info helps explain why the Hatch cars have custom support arms and transmisson mount!

We rebuilt and mounted the brake pedal box assembly with the offset pedal from the 280SE 4.5 today and moved the booster 1 1/2" left.  That should clear and looks to be about "two fingers"!  Appreciate that advice, too!

Hope you'll also keep us up to date on your 5.6 adventure!

Dick & Justin

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #10 on: August 05, 2012, 11:40:33 »
I'm not sure the 4.5 front brakes have bigger brake pads, but the rotors are vented which is surely a big plus. You may consider carbon/kevlar pads, they do a good job on my Coupe and people have good experience with them on this board.

I will be using "flatter" engine mounts to position the engine lower by one to two centimeters. I have used generic hot rod engine mounts fitted on the original back plates. I did not fit the engine on the front axle yet, so I don't know if I have enough clearance with the oil pan. If not I will see if I need to lower the front axle carrier. If I were you I would start by fitting the engine on its mounts without lowering the front axle carrier yet, and see if the flex disk works ok or if it is distorted. For that you need to have the car sitting on its wheels and turn the driveshaft. If the flex disc is distorted it will be quite obvious. Don't do this with wheels pending because the engine will sit lower due to front axle carrier mounts play. I'm saying this because I had the opposite problem on my Coupe conversion: I had to have the engine sit a bit higher for the tri-Y downpipes to clear the steering linkages etc. and I ended up with a bit of growling noises in 5th as the flex disk was distorting a bit. Agaist all odds the solution was to lower the trans mount a bit when logic would have dictated the contrary. So it's better to work on shimming at the end, also because you will have the steering system in place so that you can make sure you're not creaing another problem there.

The 4.5 front springs are the stiffer of the series so I think they will be the best suited for your application. You may end up having to shorten them a bit to have the car sit where it should, but you also will see this in the end when the car is completed.

I suppose you will be using the 4.5 3.27 rear axle too which is thee best suited for your application.

One trick: the SL auto shifter has its "P" position at the bottom, while it is up on the sedans. So just rotate the shifting arm on the trans by 180 degrees to have it work with the Pagoda shifter.

English is not my mother tongue so I do not always see immediately all the different meanings of the words I'm using. Sorry for the booster clearance explanation !

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #11 on: August 05, 2012, 13:53:58 »
Another point you may consider is that clearance between the driver side exhaust manifold and the steering box is very tight. lowering the engine may have the manifold hit the steering box. A combination of grinding on the manifold, the steering box a slightly tilting the engine to the passenger side may help you with clearance. You may also consider shifting the engine arms left with right. They are not the same length so it may shift the engine a bit towards the right. Again, check all the clearances with the weight of the car on the wheels as otherwise the front axle will sit lower than in driving conditions.

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #12 on: August 13, 2012, 16:21:40 »
Good day and thanks for all the information, GGR.

We set the engine and transmission in the car over the weekend and with a little wiggling, got it bolted to both motor mounts.  Moving over the brake assembly required us to build a new little bracket under the dash to mount the brake pedal assembly.  The brakes are ready to go, steering is reassembled and ready to be put in post wiring and ducting, and then onto engine components.

One thing we are still out looking for is a set of engine shock absorbers.  We have a set off the 4.5 (280SE) but the shock is too large for the distance covered and the bracket that mounts to the engine isn't at a good angle.  I've reached out to a few salvage yards to find a 3.5L set but haven't had any luck yet. 

Another issue is going to be finding a radiator with enough cooling capacity or trying to fit one of the SE radiators in the car.   I understand why you were interested in that right side of the engine bay now.  Fitting in a larger radiator will most likely force it to be mounted lower to allow the hood to properly close. 

Progress...  :)

Thanks again for all the advice and information.
Justin

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #13 on: August 13, 2012, 17:53:01 »
I did not use the engine shock absorbers on the Coupe conversion and I'm not planning to use them on the Pagoda conversion. I never really understood their function other than restraining the engine from bouncing around when hitting potholes (suspension pushes the axle carrier up which in turn pushes the engine up). This may be a problem on Pagodas as clearance with the hood is thight and there is a risk of damaging it. This is why there are stop plates mounted on the top of the axle carrier mounts. Using stiffer engine mounts like I will be doing may also help reducing engine movements.

Other than that I don't know where you can find 3.5 engine shocks. All the ones I've seen were shot and they cost an arm and a leg new.

Regarding the radiator, I would compare the capacity of the 280SL with the one of the 3.5. Put them flat on the floor, fill them with water and then compare capacity by emptying each in a bucket and measuring water volume. If capacity is similar, Which I belive it might be, I would just use the 280SL radiator. You may want to have it boiled and cleaned at a radiator shop and make sure the clutch fan is in good shape to contain overheating. You may have to swap oil cooler from left to right as all the piping is on the right on the 3.5. If you need to use another radiator, I would consider an r107 one rather than one out of a sedan, as the latter do not have the expansion tank system.

What engine mounts did you use?

How is your clearance between right exhaust manifold and steering box?

How is your clearance between alternator and metal sheeting around where the original air cleaner was located?

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #14 on: August 20, 2012, 13:45:23 »
Good morning!
 
We've been busy over the past week trying to get some of the parts installed.  We've managed to get the steering column in, the wiring started, and the trim work begun.  As always, a few hiccups to slow proceedings down but we are gaining ground.

To answer your questions:
1.  The motor mounts are out of the 300SEL (I can't find the part number readily).  They are the squarish rubber mounts, a little lower in profile than the stacked cones the SL uses.  The arms are 116 and seem to hold things at a useable height. 
2.  Approximately 1.1 inches between the steering box and the manifold.  It's a little tight back in there and hard to take a good measurement but that is as near as I could get the caliper.
3.  We've not yet fitted anything in the space yet.  The metal shield is still out of the car and I've been contemplating reversing the bow of the metal.  That would enable us to keep a roughly Mercedes feel to the piece, protect the computer, and get the radiator mounted.  The air cleaner is going to sit on top of the engine so it shouldn't need as much space.  Just contemplating at this time.

The quest continues for the engine shock shock absorber brackets.  We managed to get a PN off the Mercedes EPC site and now it is just a matter of tracking them down.  When I have a moment, I will get some pictures of our progress uploaded for viewing.

Have a great week!

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #15 on: August 29, 2012, 18:28:31 »
Good day to everyone.

Just thought I would drop a quick note on our progress.  We've gotten the steering assembly in all the way to the wheel.  If I make vroom vroom noises and turn the wheel back and forth, I can almost feel the wind in my hair.  ;) 

The wiring loom is getting placed and we are testing several items for fit - gauges, relays, lights, etc.  We got the convertible cover latches installed and working.  Some interior work has been done and a few of the carpet pieces put in for fit and appearance.  The brake calipers are all on with pads and rotors.  As a distraction we occasionally search through all the chrome pieces to see what is missing, what can be buffed, and what is going in for re-chroming.

Next steps:
1.  Figure out the accelerator linkage.  The engine sits fairly tight to the firewall.  Since the linkage pushes up first, then to the front of the car, a custom linkage is going to be needed.  We have a 300SEL to look at for determining fit but there is considerably more space in the engine compartment of that car.
2.  Transmission mount.  I've not gotten underneath to actually see this issue so I can't speak fully on the problem at hand.
3.  Drive shaft fitting.  The drive shaft is out for modification at the moment but when it returns we will install it and verify everything is in alignment.
3.  Finish the front and rear wiring.  The engine has several relay mounting brackets that need to be located in the compartment yet.  Since we moved the brake booster over, the bracket and relay set that fits into the space will need modified.
4.  Radiator fitting.  The radiator fitting is waiting until the radiator returns from being tested and repaired.  The oil cooler was sent in at the same time.  Once it's back, we will get the RH bracket fabricated and installed.
5.  Install the alternator, power steering pump, and AC components.  Then pray the hood closes.  :)
6.  Fix the heating and cooling controls.

It all seems like small stuff but it certainly takes up quite a bit of time.  I will try and update our progress as we make some.

Hope everyone has a great day.
Justin

stickandrudderman

  • Vendor
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • United Kingdom, England, Richmond
  • Posts: 2815
    • http://www.colinferns.com
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #16 on: August 29, 2012, 18:35:42 »
Some pictures would be nice!

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #17 on: August 30, 2012, 14:34:37 »
Here are some photos so far -

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #18 on: September 16, 2012, 15:10:21 »
Good day, everyone!

A bit of a status update.  I've been busy occupying myself with a bit of speedometer and tachometer repair work.  We happen to have a 160 MPH speedometer for a 300SEL laying about and thought it would be fun to switch the guts into the SL housing.  Before I can do that, I had to repair the gearing that turns the odometer in the speedometer so it can be swapped with the unit that is geared correctly for the differential.  I'm still working on how to pull the needle without destroying it but everything should change over correctly with some minor modifications (like switching the position of the odometer gear and drilling a hole in the face for the turn knob).  It's going to take a call to Palo Alto to get a bit of the know-how before moving forward.

Got all the interior pieces upholstered trim pieces ready to go in the interim and a goodly portion of the chrome is out for recoating.

We are currently working on getting the drivetrain in alignment.  The transmission mount is sitting up a touch high and needs a bit of modification to get the right lines.  Out of the alignment, we have noticed that the fan sits about 4" above the radiator line.  I cannot foresee the hood closing in such a state.  One option would be to cut down the fan blades.  That would need to be professionally done and balanced again.  If anyone else has suggestions, fire away. 

I will try and shoot some pictures of the fan so the problem can be seen.

Have a great day!
Justin

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #19 on: September 16, 2012, 17:13:32 »
You should fit the hood tentatively and see wwhere things fall. In my case the fan was too close to the hood with the 3.5 engine mounts. I fitted some lower mounts and clearance with the hood is now OK.

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #20 on: October 24, 2012, 20:02:35 »
Good afternoon, everyone.

Update time for those folks following our progress.

In the past week, I have been working on replacing the rear wood deck (behind the seats).  Trivial compared to everything else but getting the hardware and the planks ready is just another task in the very long list still remaining.  After having built the mirror image of the actual pieces, I remade all the pieces and have them drying from the sealing process.  Hopefully that is wrapped up in the next day or two.

In positioning the engine, we ran across another issue - the drive shaft and transmission were striking the left side of the tunnel.  The engine could be pried over a little but not enough to make the parts clear the sides correctly.  Inspecting the lot turned up a problem with the front cross/axle.  The front we had came from a donor 280SE.  The part has what appears to be three degrees of twist in it, causing the engine to mount slightly crooked.  We've since taken that front out and have begun the process of fitting in one that is straight.  Not a fun way to spend time but it seems we are now moving in the right direction again.

We've also been fabricating a right-side radiator mount that is narrower than the original.  The new one should allow the computer to be mounted behind it and still maintain the stability and strength of the original. 

The gas tank is mounted and most of the wiring loom is now in place.  Other fun progress has been mostly in the interior, fitting gauges and dash pieces.  A lot had to go out for repair and dye work.  We've since been making sure everything fits and before too long expect to fit in the windshield (and its enormous gasket).  Lots of pieces also headed out for chrome work and now need to be installed or reassembled. 

The problem of fan clearance still remains and our solution will likely be to use a low profile electric fan, common in many modern cars.  Until we sort out the front axle issues and properly fit the engine, this issue won't be addressed.

I will get some more pictures for the folks interested after I get the radiator bracket installed.

Cheers,
Justin

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #21 on: October 24, 2012, 21:03:22 »
3.5 left and right engine arms aren't the same length. Make sure you did not intervert tham as this will influence the position of the engine laterally speaking.

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #22 on: October 31, 2012, 19:08:03 »
That was our first thought as well but the problem was a twisted cross.  We pulled it out and replaced with another one that measured better and everything is fitting better.  The driveshaft fits in the tunnel correctly now.

Now that the car is back to having the front, we are on to making linkages.  We have an automatic transmission in the car with the 290SL shifter assembly.  I think I found the wrong linkage for the car because when I get it lined up on the shifter, it goes about 4 to 5 cm past the bracket on the transmission.  It may be a matter of the gear the transmission is in (I haven't fiddled with it much.)

We've also been fitting some of the front grille pieces, prepping the parts that need re-chroming and polishing other parts.  The front bracket for the radiator is almost ready.  We need to do a little modification to the oil cooler but it is almost done. 

This week is the start of brake lines and some other fun work.  More posts with progress.

Cheers!


3.5 left and right engine arms aren't the same length. Make sure you did not intervert tham as this will influence the position of the engine laterally speaking.

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #23 on: October 31, 2012, 19:49:50 »
You can turn the arm 180 degrees on the transmission so as to use the SL shifter with P at the bottom (the 3.5 one is in the top).

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #24 on: January 17, 2013, 03:44:25 »
Ah, the holidays are a great time for getting nothing done...

We've been back on task since the start of the year.  The chores we've done are
-Fitting the fuel lines including running the line to the driver's side front or a fuel filter (similar to the placement on a 300SEL)
-Fitting the brake lines
-Running the rear wiring loom
-Building a battery brace to sit behind the passenger side shock tower
-Building a bracket to mount the computer next to the modified radiator bracket
-Mounting a vacuum unit to the firewall
-Cutting down the overflow tank bracket and mounting it to the firewall beside the wiper motor
-Working on re-installing the heating duct work and flaps
-Fitting the grille surround and the grille pieces
-Rebuilding the heater controls

Right now we have the engine out of the car and will be prepping for painting the engine bay.

I will try and post some photos of the recent modifications when I get a chance.

Justin

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #25 on: January 17, 2013, 11:41:35 »
Have you considered moving the battery in the trunk or behind the passenger seat? This would restore the car balance close to stock, given that the 3.5 is heavier than the original engine.

Keep up the good work !

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #26 on: March 11, 2013, 15:19:57 »
We thought about it but wanted to try and fit it up front.  Right now, we are still after a few other issues.  If it needs to be relocated, we can run new wiring before the interior carpet get put into place.

Thanks,
Justin

Have you considered moving the battery in the trunk or behind the passenger seat? This would restore the car balance close to stock, given that the 3.5 is heavier than the original engine.

Keep up the good work !

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #27 on: March 11, 2013, 15:33:09 »
Progress updates:

We have been putting in more time on the car and made a little progress.  There has be a little three steps forward, two steps back but things are heading in a good direction.  The biggest chunk of time has been spent in the dash with various tasks.  I have been trying to refit the vents and duct work.  There is definitely a process to making sure all the bits fit correctly.

Other work has included-
Charging and bleeding the brake lines
Fitting the speedometer cable
Connecting all the dash lights
Driver and passenger vents
Installing the exhaust manifolds
New spark plugs
Windshield trim
Front cabin air flap/housing/trim installation
Fitting the fuel lines

What we are working on now includes-
Connecting up the various wiring harnesses
Grounding the dash connections
Getting the radio repaired and reinstalled
Re-installing the remaining heater parts
Installing the windshield
Installing sensors

Eventually I will remember to take pictures.  :)

Have a great week,
Justin

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #28 on: March 12, 2013, 14:58:32 »
Photos -

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #29 on: March 12, 2013, 17:22:23 »
That's really good looking !

You should make sure you have enough clearance between the closed hood and the power steering reservoir. Put the hood in before the radiator, close it and look through the grill opening. You need enough clearance for engine to bounce around when you hit a pothole.

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #30 on: March 25, 2013, 15:39:45 »
Good day!

Clearance is going to be an issue for a couple of things.  The accelerator linkage arm is a little too close to the valve covers and there is a piece for the cooling system that also sits up pretty high.  When we get our electrical issues sorted out (the car has suffered a stroke on the right side signals), we will be doing some fit work.  It feels like we are hitting the downside of the hill and hopefully will be out driving the car for summer.

Thanks and good luck with your projects.
Justin


That's really good looking !

You should make sure you have enough clearance between the closed hood and the power steering reservoir. Put the hood in before the radiator, close it and look through the grill opening. You need enough clearance for engine to bounce around when you hit a pothole.

Jim Rosenthal

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #31 on: April 14, 2013, 12:07:03 »
I don't know if you did the radiator yet, but if not, one of your options might be to have the radiator recored with a high-performance core which will increase the cooling area and capacity while retaining the same external dimensions. A good radiator shop (of which, sadly, there are fewer and fewer) should be able to spec this and do it for you. It involves removing the old core and soldering in the new one and then tank-testing it for leaks. I've done this with a couple of my Mercedes which needed the radiators cleaned and have been very satisfied with the results.

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap
« Reply #32 on: April 21, 2013, 15:06:56 »
Good day folks!

We actually are right on board with you Mr. Rosenthal.  We've already taken the original radiator in and had it re-cored to increase it's cooling capacity.  Now it is just a matter of finding a fan capable of pulling enough air through it to keep things running right.

The car is coming along after our struggles with the electrical.  We're still sorting out a couple of issues with the cabin wiring but it's to the radio at this point.  The engine bay is the current focus.  We've been getting the oil lines run for the cooler as well as filter assembly.  Transmission lines are also being fitted and run.

One of the custom things we've done is to relocate the fuel filter to a bracket on the driver's side front frame.  It's the 280SL fuel filter assembling but run more like the 300SEL. 

The vacuum lines are run and most of the injection system is in place.  The accelerator linkage is getting some tuning to make sure the pedal gives the full range throttle.  Plug wires and distribution have also been done.  There is a lot of little miscellaneous stuff to deal with in the engine bay yet but we're getting closer.

Enjoy!
Justin

pagoden

  • Full Member
  • Senior
  • ***
  • USA, MD, Silver Spring
  • Posts: 243
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #33 on: April 23, 2013, 00:48:31 »
So good to hear you folks' progress.  I got to meet Jim Rosenthal recently at a very enjoyable Mid-Atlantic spring gathering; another good fellow.  He'll be having a thread to follow here on the 5-spd Getrag conversion he's in the midst of.  And GGR was there with his very successful, sweet-running aluminum 560 transplant.  Looks like the soonest I can see your handiwork again will be in late May/early June.  Tom Phillips says he's going to an MBCA Iowa Section event of some sort in May, will take one or both 113s if possible, but I won't be there to handle his lovely old 250sl, alas.  Keep him and his R&D dept. in mind for that fan challenge of yours; I've even seen an instance (photo somewhere) of the drive motor of a SPAL fan fitted inside the barrel structure of the 113 grill star when there was no room for a fan pulling on the back side (though there ought to be with the newer fan motors and shorter V8 too, no?).
One of our members summers in WDM and is stirring up another micro Pagoda gathering this year: might be half a dozen cars attending.  Date not set but I hope I can make it, and you gents would make a fine and very popular addition.  [And how about that long-standing multi-county rod and custom run: DR have any appetite for that?  Could be good for some grins.]
P.S. I think you gents should hang on to that 'lacework' rusted-out heater box, just to give posterity an idea of how far gone the whole central cowl/firewall area must have been when you first got to it.  

  
1968/69 280SL, just+100k mi, manual 4, 3.46, both tops, 717/904

shanghaitom

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #34 on: April 23, 2013, 21:16:59 »
Quite a project you have been working on and it looks like it is turning out great!  Denny pointed me toward your posts.  I think we met at the car show in Johnston last summer...are you related to Dick?  Anyway, if you are looking for an electric cooling fan, SPAL is #1.  Drop me a line if I can help.


justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #35 on: May 20, 2013, 02:10:33 »
You met me out at Green Days as well but I am just a wrencher on the car - Dick is the owner.  We will definitely be looking you and Spal up if we can cross a few more hurdles and get to putting the radiator back in the car.  Definitely not enough clearance in ours to go with an engine mounted fan.

Hope your Mercedes is still running right along,
Justin

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #36 on: May 20, 2013, 02:24:28 »
Good day to all.

Since the homestead is powerless thanks to some inclement weather, I figure it's a good time to post an update.

We are still working on two fronts - the driver's side door and the electrical.  Fool that I am, I am taking on the electrical.  I have been working on tracing wiring from the ECU to the parts that would need to link up with the main harness.  I think there is not a whole lot of interaction, just some at the engine start safety/backup light switch on the transmission.  Power also needs to make it back to the starter relay so I think I am going to grab it off of either fuse four or six.  Mr. Remer happens to have a 300sel owner's manual complete with wiring diagram.  Once I get done tracing and modifying, I will try and scan in a copy for folks to look at.  Then it will be time to build some connectors for the relays.

 Our door is just a no fun step right now as the paint continues to misbehave.  Enough said.

I am hopeful we will get past these issues this week and start on the few other little tasks that remain.  We test fit the hood once and found the brake fluid reservoir and battery were too high.  That led to some shims in the brake booster bracket and dropping the battery tray a little lower.  The hood fits like a champ now.  We still need some pieces back from the chromer to finish up the dash, a windshield, the fuel tank evap installed, and the door put back together.  If we get the wiring done and locate an oil cooler line or two, we might be able to put in the radiator and possibly try to start the car.

Doesn't sound like too much, right? ;)

Cheers!
Justin

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #37 on: May 29, 2013, 20:31:45 »
Look kids! Progress...

Well, we got most of the front of the car put back together.  We've discovered that the radiator outlet at the bottom is pointed right at the front sway bar.  That one is going to need some fixing.  Otherwise, we have the grille and bumper on, put on the bumperettes, managed to find a few belts, and got the expansion tank mounted.  The relays are wired for the ECU but I haven't connected them to the fuse panel yet.

The door is painted and needs polished, soon to be reassembled.  Thank you paint for finally working correctly. 

Now it will be time to find all the things not yet on the wire and get the fuse panel fully wired.  I am also on the lookout for some smooth jacketing for the wire (as opposed to the corrugated wire loom stuff).  The evap tank in the back needs to be hooked up, relays mounted, fluids added, sensors checked, and (knocking on wood) no blown fuses means we might be able to start the engine.

Summer motoring around the corner...

Cheers,
Justin

Garry

  • Full Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • Australia, Victoria, Kyneton and Brisbane Queensland
  • Posts: 5183
  • Audit Committee
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #38 on: May 29, 2013, 21:56:01 »
That looks like it is going in nicely.  How do you go for bonnet/hood clearance at the forward part of the engine.
Garry Marks
Melbourne/ Kyneton, Brisbane. Australia
1969 MB 280SL 5 speed RHD SOLD.
1965 MB 230SL Auto RHD Lt Blue 334G, Top 350H, 213 Leather, Tourist Delivery.
1972 MB 280CE Auto RHD 906G Blue Grey
2005 MB A200.
2006 MB B200
2019 Izuzu DMax 4x4 with Slide-on camper.
2022 Volvo XC40 Twin Electric

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #39 on: June 10, 2013, 16:50:24 »
Good day and thank you.

We are doing pretty well on the clearance.  The radiator and tank clear nicely.  The little vacuum at the firewall was up too high and needed to be lowered.  The brake fluid reservoir was also up too high so I used some shims on the brake booster bracket to get it pointed lower.  The battery continues to be at issue, especially since my attempt to run the tank line underneath it raised it up slightly so one corned was touching the hood.  We're still sorting out that problem as well making sure the relays don't stick up too much.  I created a bracket to mount right next to the ECU but haven't mounted anything yet.

That looks like it is going in nicely.  How do you go for bonnet/hood clearance at the forward part of the engine.

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #40 on: June 10, 2013, 17:09:12 »
Greeting folks.

We have been getting a little bit done but running across a few problems along the way.  What project doesn't have those lovely memories?

The hoses are all run now to the various parts of the cooling system.  Several of the hoses had to be customized (as expected) to reach the various destinations but so far, none are leaking. 

The transmission has been a little less cooperative.  It is an automatic transmission with P-4.  The gear selector shaft out of the transmission is leaking fluid ever so slightly.  More importantly, the bracket we built to attach to the shift linkage did not line up quite right to properly get the starter lockout and back up lights working.  That was a long time ordeal as the bracket is tight in against the tunnel wall.  Nothing like cramped space to try and work in.  The shifting and switch now are in good order.

That leaves the wiring.  We've been putting in new wiring to accommodate the different relays and connections.  Alas, that part is not going as well.  I am still troubleshooting the connections trying to find the problems that prevent the engine from turning over.  The ECU complicates matters a little but the old wiring harness is available for referencing wire colors and guessing relay locations.  The other half is making sure things are tied to the fuse panel in proper spots.  I've attached the 300SEL wiring diagram with colors so people can see what I am doing.  When I have stuff working, I am going to attempt to reconcile the two wiring systems and create a unified diagram.

Other wise, we are still waiting on chrome pieces for the dash to finish that bit up.  And I need to reach out to SPAL and find a fan that is going to work for the car.  If the wiring can be sorted, we should be able to get to work on the interior and finishing up the exhaust.  It's definitely starting to feel downhill.

Onwards and happy motoring to all,
Justin

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap
« Reply #41 on: June 17, 2013, 16:02:10 »
Greetings!

I really want to rename this thread "The 3-2 Step Dance".  Three steps forwards, two steps back.

Over the weekend, the engine was turned by key switch for the first time.  It was really fun to hear the chuff-chuff sound, especially with no exhaust pipes on.  However, it was zero fun trying to sort out the problems in the prior week or so to get to this point.

First, we had to pull the starter.  When directly energized from the battery, nothing would happen.  Once out of the car, we learned that the solenoid was locked open and the motor was having issues.  Not a big deal except the work it takes to get the starter out with the bigger motor.  The transmission had to be drained so the filler tube (which now obstructs one of the starter bolts) could be moved.  Then the wiring and harness bracket had to come off the starter.  Finally, the starter had to be fished out the right front tire as there is no other way to take it out.  A good thing for those contemplating this project to keep in mind.

Starter repaired, it was time to look at why there was no power to the trigger.  Dismantled and jumpered, the wiring issue was traced back to the module on the back of the key switch, under the dash.  The proper way to dismantle it would be to take out the speedometer and center instrument cluster.  The only problem is that the speedometer cable is really tight which would require all sorts of work to be able to re-attach it.  Since the windshield is still out, we used a different method.  The plastic vent box at the bottom of the dash was disconnected from the fan.  With some wiggle room, we bent two cabinet flat blade screwdrivers to 100 degrees and used them to take out the three screws on the back of the key switch (two from the bottom, one from the upper vent hole).  With the module out, testing confirmed that it was getting inconsistent resistance across the 15 to 50 terminals.  And yes, getting it back in was no fun either.

Reassembled with all the wiring attached and the relays checked, the key finally turned the engine.  Feeling brave at that point, we put some gas in the tank and thought how awesome it would be to see if it fired.  The car repair gods chortled mightily.  After trying the key and getting nothing, a timing light revealed that there was no juice getting to the plugs.  That was only a temporary distraction.   I initially inspected the lines for leaks when we put gas in but quit watching when we were trying to start the car.  Under pressure, the fuel pump began leaking in a steady stream from multiple spots.  Luckily, nothing caught fire.  The fuel pump removed and inspected.  It is missing at least one o-ring and possibly was rebuilt incorrectly.  Argh.

The moral of the story is that whenever possible, test those used components before putting them into the car.  We tested the fuel pump but not with gas in it.  The module on the backside of the key was never tested.  The starter was tested and working but apparently decided to quit. 

This week will be waiting on a new fuel pump and tidying up the wiring.  Other than ironing out the problems that pop up, we are getting closer.  We still have to figure out what is going wrong with the ignition, possibly a bad resistor (already had one go bad) or the transistorized ignition box.  If we get lucky, it may result in a running car. 

Enjoy,
Justin


justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #42 on: June 24, 2013, 18:11:52 »
Greetings!

Vroom, deafening vroom!  We managed to sort out our fuel leaks and fired up the engine for the first time this weekend.  Major milestone achieved.  The timing wasn't all that great but the engine was running on it's own after about two seconds of turning the key. 

I make it sound like it was all well and good after the fuel system troubleshooting but we also ran into a problem with the armature in the distributor.  The switch was made to a Pertronix ignitor and FlameThrower coil.  We couldn't get any fire out of the ignitor so switched back to points.  It may be that a bad part got sent our way but the points fired up like a champ.   

The wiring is mostly sorted at this point.  The electronic tachometer out of a 280SE Cabriolet is getting used which means some additional wiring is needed.  There's something called an Adapter (tachometer) needed and I haven't been able to find its part number on EPC.  Otherwise, the wiring is pretty simple and leaves only the lights in the tach to be figured out.

Other fun resolutions included replacing the brake fluid reservoir.  The original one had a small leak and repairs to it were unsuccessful.  We are still fiddling with the accelerator travel.  The peddle can either fully close the throttle or fully open it but not both.  It may require a modification to the spring arm on the linkage to give it greater travel distance.  Unfortunately, that arm is currently going right into a vacuum line.

The next steps include fixing the timing and finding out what would be needed to fabricate the front half of the exhaust.  Still waiting on the windshield installation and a few pieces of chrome.  Once those are in hand, it will be time to put together the interior. 

Getting there,
Justin

justininia

  • Guest
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #43 on: October 18, 2013, 15:07:05 »
Good day, everyone.

It has been some time since I have posted.  We have been slowly trying to troubleshoot the problems on the 280 while also working on another car. 

The engine is running fairly well.  It appears the timing is still a bit of an issue even though the engine idles at 1100 RPM.  The idle is revving, then relaxing before revving again.  No misfires during fire but it appears the vacuum advance may be causing the issue.  We are continuing to troubleshoot the issue.

Another fun problem is in the wiring.  We have to track down whatever is backfeeding power as the car will not shut off with the driver side door open.  That's a bit of a weird one as the door circuit is fairly isolated from everything else.  Having done the engine wiring, I suspect I may have gotten something crossed where it shouldn't be. 

I am also researching if the connectors and parts can be purchased to remake the engine wiring loom.  The one we have is very brittle and might be causing some other bits of fun.  Hopefully someone out in the world still makes the plastic injector connectors.

We have also been searching for a Mercedes mechanic in the Des Moines area to take a look over everything.  We are kind of to the point where some more expert advice on a few of the problems is needed. 

In the things that have gone right category, I did manage to get the engine fan cut down and balanced.  This doesn't remove the need to consider an electric fan but it gives us the ability to run the engine.  Mr. Hatch recommended using a larger radiator out of a different Mercedes but we have stuck with the re-cored 280SL radiator for the time being.  The radiator he liked is much larger and would require additional modification to the engine bay.

That's pretty much the updates for now.  Hope everyone had a great summer.
Justin

GGR

  • Associate Member
  • Platinum
  • ******
  • USA, DC, Washington
  • Posts: 1470
Re: 280SL 3.5L Engine swap requirements and contact
« Reply #44 on: October 18, 2013, 16:58:26 »
Hi,

Good progress! For idle running high and going up and down, make sure the throttle closes completely and that the throttle position sensor is positioned properly (test it as per W/shop manual procedure) and tells the calculator that throttle is closed when it is so. This is quite a common issue on D-jet and I would rather look on the injection side ratherthan to the ignition side.

Engine not shutting with the open door rings a bell, but I don't remember what. You may want to post the issue in the electrical section of the forum.

I 'm curious about the radiator Hatch recommended you. I've been trying many and it's quite tricky due to the position of the hood when open and its travel path while shutting. Make sure you position whatever radiator with the hood in place to make sure it all works well. Fitting a bigger radiator may be possible by mounting it more backwards. But then clearance with the fan will be an issue. Hatch used home made engine brackets and I guess their engine sits a bit more backwards compared to yours.

Are you still using the oil cooler? If not it will give you more options for the radiator.

I've been looking and wiring connectors a couple of years ago when I was building my coupe and they were still available on the net. However, I heard about this engine loom being refabricated. Not cheap, but building one is time consuming.